The manatees of Crystal River
In the Florida town of Crystal River people can swim with manatees, but some question whether this is a good idea
Weighing 550 kilos or more, the manatee looks something like a chubby dolphin or small whale, though it's related to neither. In fact, it shares a common ancestor with elephants. Manatees lack the layer of fat that allows whales to tolerate cold, so they are unable to survive in water below 20°C. The species found in the United States is the Florida manatee. In winter, when sea temperatures drop, they gather inland at natural springs and other sources of warm water.
The town of Crystal River, on Florida's west coast, is built around a magnificent lake called Kings Bay. Springs scattered around the lake pump out fresh water at a constant 22°C year round. (37)………….. As a result, during winter, Crystal River residents can walk out their doors and see dozens of manatees swimming, resting, and sleeping in the city's canals and waterways.
This situation, along with other unique circumstances, has made Crystal River the manatee capital of the United States. Nowhere else have people been encouraged to enter the water and swim with manatees. Here, people have got used to approaching them, interacting with them, and even touching them. (38)………...... However, the activity has long been a popular tourist draw at Crystal River, pre-dating the Endangered Species Act and the creation of a local wildlife refuge.
Most experts agree that many of the 150,000 people who come to Crystal River each year to swim with the manatees leave with an increased appreciation of the animals. (39)………….. A few years ago, local activist Tracy Colson began making videos of examples that she witnessed and posting them online. These helped bring about stricter guidelines for interaction with manatees.
Patrick Rose, an aquatic biologist and director of the powerful Save the Manatee Club, somewhat reluctantly supports the practice of swimming with manatees, though he's determined to see changes made. He explains that most manatees prefer to stay away from humans (40)…...……… At this time, especially, they avoid all contact with people.
Rose is campaigning for stricter rules requiring swimmers to stop a body length away from the animals. (41)……..…….. Colson agrees that there should be no touching. As she says, manatees are wild animals, not pets. Rose believes that the majority of Crystal River dive shops, which arrange tours for people to watch or swim with manatees, are trying to do a good job. As long as they take their responsibilities seriously, he is happy for them to continue.
Estimates of the contribution of manatee-related tourism to the local economy range from $20 million to $30 million a year. Some dive-shop owners claim they'd lose substantial business if customers weren't able to go home and tell friends, ‘I touched a manatee.’ Aware that their livelihood could be at risk, 16 tour operators have formed an organisation to work with the wildlife refuge and the Save the Manatee Club. (42)..………….. Together, they have now voluntarily adopted rules on human-manatee interaction that are sometimes even stricter than those required by national law.